Oldest Sibling Struggles: Is “Oldest Child Syndrome” Real?

Oldest child syndrome refers to how birth order can affect a child’s development and even shape their personality and sense of identity. Whether you’re the eldest of your siblings or are interested in how it could affect your own firstborn, keep reading for an overview of how oldest child syndrome manifests and strategies to manage it.

Contents:

• What is Oldest Child Syndrome?
• Signs and Characteristics of Oldest Child Syndrome
• Impact of Oldest Child Syndrome on Development
• How Does Oldest Child Syndrome Affect Adulthood?
• Practical Strategies for Managing Oldest Child Syndrome For Parents
• Managing Oldest Child Syndrome as an Adult
• FAQs

What is Oldest Child Syndrome?

Juri J Holmes/Shutterstock

Firstborn children, in terms of oldest child syndrome, are generally characterized as being responsible individuals with a strong sense of ambition and drive, and who are drawn towards leadership positions, both in their families and in their lives in general.

According to the oldest child syndrome, birth order can have a profound impact on family dynamics and a child’s personality, development, and temperament, with typical eldest child traits including perfectionism and a heightened sense of responsibility.

Signs and Characteristics of Oldest Child Syndrome

Firstborns may be more likely to demonstrate certain characteristics. Here are some of the key signs that either you or your eldest child has oldest child syndrome.

A Tendency Towards Perfectionism

Perfectionism and being an overachiever are classic signs of oldest child syndrome. Many eldest children place high expectations on themselves and feel anxious about failing, making mistakes, or not doing something as well as they think they should.

Strong Sense of Responsibility

Being the eldest child in the family often means taking on additional responsibilities, such as helping with household tasks or caring for a younger sibling. This can result in a heightened sense of duty, which may persist throughout adult life.

A “Leadership” Temperament

Often going hand-in-hand with a greater sense of responsibility, many of the oldest kids demonstrate leadership personality traits, and a maturity that’s beyond their years. For example, these children may be the ones to assign tasks to their other siblings or decide on the rules of a game.

Ready for a fun fact? This tendency to leadership is backed up by the fact that the CEOs of some of the world’s biggest companies—Jezz Bezos, Elon Musk, and Richard Branson—are all firstborns!

A Competitive Attitude

It’s completely normal for sibling rivalry to raise its head when former “onlies” suddenly find themselves confronted with a new little brother or sister. This rivalry can create a growing sense of competitiveness, with the eldest child viewing their younger sibling as taking away parents’ time and attention.

Rule-Following, Conservative Behavior

Firstborns tend to follow rules and exhibit conservative behavior. They may act as a “little parent” to younger siblings and be generally more cautious and averse to risk-taking. Instead, these children adopt a more “serious” approach and act older than their years.

Heightened Sensitivity to Criticism

Having often been held to comparatively higher standards from a young age, oldest children may exhibit a heightened sensitivity to criticism and tend to take even constructive criticism personally. This can affect their relationships and sense of self-esteem.

Difficulty Adapting to Change

Often, an eldest child appreciates structure, routine, and clear expectations, and may find adapting to change a real challenge. They can also find environments where they have less or limited control, which can be particularly difficult.

Reliable and Dependable

The reliable, dependable nature of many firstborns means that they may become the family “rock” or the person leaned on in times of need. While this is generally a positive character trait, it can lead to these children, in later life, being overly burdened with others’ expectations and problems.

An Over-Protective Nature

Firstborns, often due to their experience as a child looking after younger siblings, may develop an overprotective nature, keen to shield those they care about from a host of perceived dangers or hurts. While this comes from a place of love, it can cause issues regarding the growing independence of those they’re trying to protect.

Difficulty Asking for Help

As the go-to “responsible” sibling, a firstborn may find it difficult to ask for help or admit they’re struggling, believing they’re a failure to feel this way. A fear of showing vulnerability can also contribute to this trait. Struggling on in silence rather than speaking up can be a sign of oldest child syndrome, and a tendency that, again, may shape adult habits and relationships.

Preference for Adult Company

Have you noticed that your firstborn often prefers the company of adults to other children? This is something commonly seen in eldest siblings, who feel more aligned with other adults due to their sense of responsibility.

High Confidence and Self-Esteem

It’s possible that firstborns have a higher sense of self-esteem and confidence, which can help them in the classroom and adult life. This may come from taking their parents’ lead, and feeling pride at being able to “take care” of their younger sibling and teach them new things and skills. This can lead to social issues, however, if the firstborn isn’t able to fulfil this role within their circle of friends.

Challenges with Sibling Rivalry

For firstborns, the arrival of a new baby brother or sister can be particularly challenging. Suddenly, they’re not the only child in the family, and can feel as if the younger sibling is in direct competition for their parents’ time and emotional resources. Jealousy can easily emerge, and it’s important for parents to recognize the unique challenges firstborns experience when their familial status changes from “only” to “eldest.”

Impact of Oldest Child Syndrome on Development

Oksana Kuzmina/Shutterstock

Oldest child syndrome can have a significant impact on development. Australian psychoanalyst and doctor Alfred Adler theorized that both youngest and firstborn children experience anxieties based on their need for dominance and success within the family. A middle child, he posited, is more likely to be rebellious or easy-going. Although these are generalizations that have, today, been questioned, when it comes to parenting an eldest child in your own family, perhaps this is something you can relate to.

Mental health is just one of the potential impacts of the oldest child syndrome. For example, if a firstborn has too many responsibilities placed on them when young, they may feel, later in life, as though they missed out on their childhood. Further, a family environment that lacks healthy boundaries can cause problems such as depression and anxiety in the older sibling.

There are positives, too, though, to being the oldest child. These kids often demonstrate advantages in quantitative and verbal skills in early childhood, reaching developmental milestones comparatively more quickly. Plus, the additional responsibilities that firstborns often take on mean they may mature faster, emotionally.

However, in family dynamics, oldest child syndrome can result in the firstborn taking on a quasi-parental role towards their younger siblings, making it sometimes a challenge for them to develop outside of their role within the family unit.

How Does Oldest Child Syndrome Affect Adulthood?

It’s not uncommon for the effects of oldest child syndrome to last into adulthood, but understanding its origins and how to manage it can make a real difference. It’s also important to recognize that the personality traits of oldest child syndrome can be positive, making firstborns sometimes more independent, confident, and resilient. Remember, too, that there is a plethora of factors that can shape personality and childhood development, with birth order just one piece of a vast jigsaw. Parenting style, home environment, the presence of role models, and much more will all play their part.

How eldest children are brought up can impact all areas of their adult lives, including the ability to form healthy relationships, work, social skills, and sense of self. Regarding relationships, eldest children may still subconsciously seek an authoritative role in their adult connections, which could cause issues. At work, a tenancy to rigidity could manifest as inflexibility and create challenges around collaboration. Many firstborns find delegating tasks difficult. Having assumed responsibility for younger siblings, they may tend to think, as an adult, that “no one else can do it right” and be reluctant to hand over the reins of control.

If, as an adult, you’re struggling with mental health issues or some of the challenges we’ve discussed above, talking to a qualified therapist could be a good idea. Therapy can help uncover how oldest child syndrome may be continuing to impact your adult life, and create strategies to manage your feelings and move on positively. Combining therapy with regular self-care practices can be extremely powerful in uplifting mood and changing mindsets.

Practical Strategies for Managing Oldest Child Syndrome For Parents

Recognizing the presence or possibility of oldest child syndrome is the first step in making a strategy to manage it. There are two main elements to helping ensure your firstborn enjoys a positive childhood experience in their role as the eldest sibling. The first is setting balanced expectations that empower your child to be a role model without them feeling (or being) overwhelmed with responsibilities. The second is making a consistent effort to foster your firstborn’s individual growth, so that their familial role does not overshadow or hinder their childhood development.

Some actionable steps to take to ensure these things could include:

• Not giving your eldest child too many responsibilities regarding the care of younger siblings. Encourage them to be a role model, but don’t expect them to take on a parent or guardian role.
• Setting balanced, moderate expectations and helping your firstborns view mistakes as learning opportunities, not failures. Praise effort as well as achievement.
• Not putting pressure on your child to be “perfect” or pushing them too hard.
• Recognizing that every child is unique with their own personality and needs, beyond birth order, and adjusting your parenting style accordingly, rather than adopting a one-size-fits-all approach.
• Spending quality, one-to-one time with your firstborn, and taking care to properly listen to how they’re feeling.
• Taking care to provide your eldest with plenty of opportunities to learn and grow, and not spending too much time caring for younger siblings. Perhaps this could be taking them to a class to learn a new skill, or making sure they have regular play dates with friends of their own age.
• As they get older, allowing them to become more independent by, for example, letting them walk the short distance to school on their own or going out to play with friends. This can be worrying for many parents—consider using a parental control app such as Findmykids, which allows you to track your kids’ location when they’re out and about.
• Fostering healthy sibling relationships by encouraging mutual respect, collaboration, and age-appropriate responsibilities. This can be an effective means of mitigating feelings of resentment and sibling rivalry, both now and in the future.
• Being consistent with household rules. Sometimes, parents are more lenient with younger siblings. Perhaps your oldest child always had a strict bedtime, whereas you’re more flexible with your youngest. These inconsistencies can build resentment and fuel sibling rivalry.
• Ensuring your child has plenty of time to just be a kid—this means allowing them to let off steam, being silly (in a supervised capacity), and freeing their imaginations.
• Being open to supporting and listening to the feelings of your firstborn, and creating a home atmosphere where they feel safe discussing things that are bothering or upsetting them.
• Modeling healthy behavior and habits yourself, such as the ability to cope with criticism and set boundaries.

Managing Oldest Child Syndrome as an Adult

Sokor Space/Shutterstock

If your own childhood experiences have caused oldest child syndrome, there are many things you can do to improve things now and reframe your feelings going forward to bring balance. The first step is redefining your role within the family. It’s important to see yourself as a sibling, rather than a parental figure, and to understand that you are not responsible for your younger siblings. Try to let go of the pressure to be a perfect caretaker or role model, and pay attention to your own feelings and needs.

Next, try to explore your identity outside of the family unit and your traditional role within it. Take some time for mindfulness and self-reflection. Interrogate where some of your habits and mindsets have come from. Why, for example, do you feel the need to be a people pleaser? If this no longer serves you, then it’s time to release this tendency. By taking a careful, empathetic look at your motivations, you’ll be better able to change patterns of behavior and find fulfillment in your own unique personality.

Oldest Child Syndrome: Challenges and Opportunities

Recognizing oldest child syndrome and its impact is a crucial element of understanding how it could be affecting both your parenting style and your child’s development. It could even help you get a better handle on your own childhood experience, and make sense of some of the things you’ve maybe struggled with in adult life.

Oldest child syndrome doesn’t need to be negative. The responsibilities we felt as an eldest sibling may have made us a little inflexible, but also a more compassionate, independent adult. There are always two sides to a coin. However, oldest child syndrome can have a significant effect on kids’ development, so it’s vital, as parents, to learn how to balance our firstborn’s needs and ensure we’re giving them the emotional tools they need to be happy both now and in the future.

FAQs

What are the symptoms of oldest child syndrome?

Signs of oldest child syndrome include perfectionism, a heightened sense of responsibility and desire for approval, difficulty relaxing, leadership tendencies, social maturity, difficulty adapting to change, inflexibility, and sensitivity to criticism.

Is the eldest daughter syndrome a real thing?

While not an official mental health diagnosis, eldest daughter syndrome, as defined by some psychologists, describes the responsibilities and experiences sometimes faced by firstborn daughters.

What is the personality of the oldest child?

While all children are different, and numerous factors shape a child’s development and personality, certain traits are commonly observed in firstborn children. These include a tendency toward perfectionism and people-pleasing, a heightened sense of responsibility, ambition, competitiveness, inflexibility, stubbornness, intelligence, and maturity.

Why do firstborns struggle?

According to the oldest child syndrome, firstborns may struggle due to a high level of expectations and responsibilities placed on them. Oldest siblings may also find it difficult to develop their own roles outside of the family unit, or experience their parents being unwilling to let them become more independent.

Cover image: Tatyana Korotun/Shutterstock